published on in game

Super Paper Mario Mafia - The End of All Worlds - The Dark Prognostics Prevails! | Page 14

Ideas I'm willing to entertain:

1) There's a mafia framer
2) Our backup cop is an insane cop
3) Zenax's check was false, or a mafia ploy
4) The backup cop is lying (more likely since he only had to claim to Zexy)
5) Zexy is godfather and the backup cop himself is a lie
6) Mafia can elect to make all inspections appear guilty on a given night (save this idea for future mafia games)

I guess it comes down to what @Yato; claims. @Zexy; I'm more inclined to trust Zenax than not.

Three is my best hope, one makes sense, dear god hope it is not two, although HumanDawn told me privately that back-up cops have been insane in the past. Four is a bit risky for that person, as we would lynch them sooner or later. Not to mention that there is a character fitting back-up cop. Six is just too strange of a role. but the truth is five of course, now lynch zenax plz bwahahahaha
I’m not as inclined to trust him, but if anyone feels like Yato is a better lynch choice, okay with that. If there's a Back up Cop it has to be Tiptron, although if the Mafia is knowledgeable about the game they could have fakeclaimed it in mind.

The thing I don't get is why would either Zenax or the Back up Cop lie, if either of their target flips Town they'd both be heavily seen as suspicious.

EXACTLY. I agree 101% with every single word of this post. I don't know why I flipped mafia from a check. I'm Vanilla.

It's basically a CC - just lynch either me or Zenax to see who's lying. That's the quickest way to sort things out.

Zenax doesn't either... And both of your claims can be seen as scummy, unfortunately :( Ok, I will choose Yato as like Rabbit said she's the one acting suspicious, whereas I don't really think Zenax has and if I am being forced to pick between the two, who I think is more likely Mafia, my guts telling me its more likely Yato.

So I will

Unvote: UltimateMaximus
Vote: Yato

Well, to be honest, both are suspicious. I explained why Zenax is in a paragraph earlier, and looks like these were both Beck's and the backup's thoughts, which led to a check on him. This similar-CC situation, though, is a different matter. If my death will uncover a fake'd check or a lie and expose who's really mafia, then I'd gladly take the lynch.

1. If I flip town, Zenax is mafia for trying to get me killed with a fake'd check.
2. If I flip mafia, Zexy is mafia for trying to frame Zenax when Zenax could have gotten the results of a framing job done on me.

Of course the lynch can lead to other results, but those two are probably most likely. Again, not 100%, but as this is similar to a CC situation, it's usually one or the other.

vote: Yato

For one, flip mafia please xD Another, if you flip mafia, this does not mean I am mafia too. While there is minor chance I am godfather, I would call the back-up cop claim I got more suspicious. Besides, as Phoenicks explained, the scenarios are endless. Anything could have happened. When we were talking about the no kills, you were the first person to note this, but this time around, you stick to one possible outcome and try to make me look mafia. It is somewhat hypocritical (you even said that it can lead to other results, but we should only focus on these two which are likely, eh?!), combined with how you are willing to get lynched and your claim is nothing important, I can't help but have a little hunch that both of you are mafia and you are the one getting bussed. Assuming you turn up mafia of course. Yato; I find it odd that you're voting for yourself. Why would you lose just to help the town out? As Phoenicks said, if you're a town member, why make us waste time by voting you instead of trying to help us figure out who's a mafia member? But I suppose it's true that if you were a mafia member, you wouldn't try to help the town.

Would it be preposterous of me to think that both Zenax and Yato are mafia members who are trying to clear one of them so that they can fool us? I feel that it's strange how they're both claiming to be townies yet are entertaining the idea of them being mafia members.

Yes, I am glad I am not the only person who can see through this.

Would it be preposterous of me to think that both Zenax and Yato are mafia members who are trying to clear one of them so that they can fool us? I feel that it's strange how they're both claiming to be townies yet are entertaining the idea of them being mafia members.


Not impossible, but it wouldn't pass Occam's Razor. Why bus each other (when neither has been particularly suspected) when they could let us flounder lynching some townie? DING-DONG! I have the answer! I have already told a few people about Zenax who turned mafia by the time he did it. You were one of said people. What if one of them was mafia and knew that Zenax would get in the spotlight sooner or later, so they decided to pull off this big stunt to throw town off? If I flip Mafia = IF I'M TAILORED or something.

Which is why I'm not saying I'm defending myself by simply saying "I'm town so don't lynch me. You CAN lynch me, but I'll flip town anyways." There's always the possibility I'll flip mafia by chance.

There could be a tailor + framer combination where I got tailored and framed and Zenax got a mafia check on me. Maybe it's a stretch, but it's not impossible. Which is why I'm not making any guarantees I'll flip 100% town when I'm lynched even if I am.

Farfetched, to be honest. Anyways, you are getting lynched so it will be all clear soon.

ncG1vNJzZmiapaGvorPAq5uepl6jsrV7yKebnrBepbWxi9OhqZ6ZlKh8tMHPnqlmqJGlsrN5zJqpoqddoq6ntcBmq6GdXZq7pXnOn2SapJxixLC%2By52qZqyYmnqlrdGkZKmqn5y7sL%2FTopqsZaCnsretyKWqZ2lma4V3f46pmKCdXWaB